The remarkable legal threat made to Congress and the remarkable response it received

Congress shows how to stand up to the president’s bullies

*

Last week a remarkable constitutional threat was made, and that threat met with an even more remarkable response.

The threat was by means of a letter sent by William Scharf, the counsel to the United States president Donald Trump. The letter is here and it should be read carefully.

The letter was sent to Democrat congressman Robert Garcia, the incoming chair of the House Oversight Committee.

The letter had three qualities: it was inappropriate, it was (clumsily) intimidating, and it was weak.

It was inappropriate because the executive really should not be in the business of trying to bully legislators performing their constitutional function in overseeing the executive.

It was (clumsily) intimidating. The letter said expressly that the legislators were being watched (“monitored”) and warned the legislators darkly of criminal law consequences.

And the letter was weak. Here we can use an old friend of this blog, the Clear-o-Meter. Generally speaking the more a legal letter relies on the word clear the weaker the letter. This is because any proposition which is actually clear does not need to be described as such, because it is (well) clear.

In this letter, we have:

“foundational limits […] which you and members of the new Congress have evinced a clear intent to transgress”

“Failure to do so in this context represents a clear abuse of power and an affront to our constitutional system of government and to the rule of law.”

“make it abundantly clear that any forthcoming investigative processes will be deployed to harass and aggrandize, rather than to advance any legitimate legislative end.”

“Beyond being inconsistent with the clear, well-recognized constitutional limitations on your investigative functions […]”

That’s quite a high score on the Clear-o-Meter for a fairly short letter.

There is even an “abundantly clear”, which gets bonus points.

All this is a mark of weak legal letter writing.

*

Another amusing feature of the letter is its use of footnotes.

Here we will recall that the president and senior members of the administration casually and frequently post the most unpleasant and incendiary things on social media, and they do so in a way which they believe is or should be inconsequential.

In contrast this letter treats the posts of Democrats with pompous solemnity:

That someone in the administration, perhaps even the author, collected and then earnestly typed out all these posts as footnotes to an aggressive legal letter is preposterous.

*

So what sort of response should this exercise in bullying silliness have?

Should the recipients try and address supposed “legitimate concerns” and placate and appease the bully? Should they (ahem) “clarify” their true position? Should they write an equal and opposite reply, full of vague counter-threats and portentous footnotes?

No.

Garcia did not even reply to the letter as such (that is with another letter), but published a response to the world.

And it was glorious.

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Today, Rep. Robert Garcia, Ranking Member of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, released the following statement after the White House sent a letter to Oversight Democrats threatening to infringe upon the Committee’s constitutionally protected right to conduct congressional oversight.

“It appears Donald Trump has something to hide. Let’s be clear: Congress’ authority comes from Article I of the Constitution, not from the permission of the White House. Congress has wide latitude to conduct investigations and oversight, an authority inherent in the power to legislate.

The American people voted overwhelmingly for us to pass laws to root out corruption and abuse. The Trump Administration continues to weaponize the government with threats of unconstitutional attacks on Congress. We are a co-equal branch of government and will not be deterred by baseless threats from a weaponized DOJ or from the President’s lawyers,” said Ranking Member Robert Garcia.

(Garcia loses one mark for a “clear” but we can let that pass as playful.)

*

Garcia’s substantive point is well made: “Congress’ authority comes from Article I of the Constitution, not from the permission of the White House […] We are a co-equal branch of government and will not be deterred by baseless threats from a weaponized DOJ or from the President’s lawyers […]”.

Spot-on.

This is how you stand up to bullies and their bullying legal letters.

**

This is a follow-on post to my Weekly Constitutional post at Prospect magazine, which you can read here.

Leave a Reply