A close reading of the legal threat made to Senator Warren

17th November 2026

The United States attorney describes the letter as an “arrow shot” – but it is not much of an arrow

*

Another day, another threatening letter from the United States executive to the legislature.

Yesterday this blog briefly dealt with a weak and clumsy threatening letter to a Democrat congressman from a White House attorney and the heartening response that it received.

*

Today’s letter is not from a White House attorney, but it is instead from Aaron Reitz, the United States attorney for the southern district of Texas.

The letter was sent to Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren at her senate address in Washington DC.

This is the letter, and it is worth reading carefully.

Page 1 U.S. Department of Justice United States Attorney’s Office Southern District of Texas 1000 Louisiana Suite 2300 Houston, Texas 77002 November 15, 2026 The Honorable Elizabeth Warren United States Senate 311 Hart Senate Office Building Washington, DC 20510 Subject: Preservation Demand (Conduct Implicating 18 U.S.C. §§ 241–42) Dear Senator Warren: One week after the 2026 midterm elections, you spoke with Margaret Brennan on Face the Nation.¹ She noted that you, the “expected incoming Senate Banking Committee chair,” have said that “you want to bring big tech CEOs, Wall Street executives, and giant corporations who may have broken the law to face consequences.”² You enthusiastically agreed, adding that these people “better get ready for some investigations—serious ones.”³ The context sends a strong smoke signal: you intend to target private individuals close to President Trump. In the same interview, you excoriated a “White House that wouldn’t enforce the laws” and a “White House that dropped investigations [and] that said, oh, if you make a nice contribution to Donald Trump’s ballroom then there won’t be any enforcement of the law.”⁴ Your Time Magazine op-ed confirms those you intend to target along your warpath: “With astonishing brazenness, Trump has attempted to reengineer the federal government into a corruption machine designed to rake in profits for himself, his family, and his cronies.”⁵ Your November 11 letter is more pointed still. Joined by Senator Blumenthal and Representative Garcia, each a recipient of a letter from my office and the White House Counsel’s Office, you wrote to a private citizen demanding sweeping information about her and other private citizens and entities who associate with President Trump.⁶
Congress use investigations to exercise the powers of criminal prosecution reserved to the Executive and Judicial branches.⁹ Moreover, the “freedom to engage in association for the advancement of beliefs and ideas is an inseparable aspect” of our Constitution and way of life.¹⁰ The American people are entitled to freely associate without their elected officials terrorizing them with aggressive, harassing government action. Your war cries directed at private American citizens and entities for associating with President Trump may run afoul of this constitutional right. For these reasons, I am writing to give you formal notice of your obligation to preserve all documents, communications, and other electronically stored information relevant to your intent to weaponize congressional investigations and deprive citizens of their core constitutional rights in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 241 and 242. You are obligated to preserve all potentially relevant evidence related to your efforts to suppress associational activities related to President Trump and the Trump Administration. Failure to do so may result in sanctions, adverse-inference instructions, or other penalties, and may carry significant legal consequences. This demand applies to you, your staff, employees, agents, consultants, campaign personnel, and any other person acting on your behalf or in concert with you. Please confirm in writing by 6:00 p.m. Eastern Time on November 23, 2026, that you have received this letter and have taken steps to preserve the materials described above. Respectfully, Aaron F. Reitz United States Attorney   Footnotes 1.	Full transcript of “Face the Nation with Margaret Brennan,” CBS News (Nov. 8, 2026), available at https://www.cbsnews.com/news/full-transcript-face-the-nation-with-margaret-brennan-11-08-2026. 2.	Id. 3.	Id.; see also Wall St. executives should prepare for oversight under Senator Elizabeth Warren, aide says, Reuters (Nov. 9, 2026), available at https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/wall-st-executives-should-prepare-oversight-under-senator-elizabeth-warren-aide-2026-11-09. 4.	Id. 5.	Senator Elizabeth Warren: Why Democrats Won the Midterms, Time (Nov. 5, 2026), available at senate.gov. 6.	Warren, Garcia, Blumenthal Probe Top Trump Fundraiser Meredith O’Rourke Regarding the President’s Vanity Projects, Warren Press Releases (Nov. 12, 2026), available at senate.gov. 7.	Warren, Lawmakers Open Investigation into Republicans’ Massive Trump Tax Subsidies for Big Tech’s AI Spending, Warren Press Releases (Sep. 28, 2026), available at senate.gov. 8.	Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178, 187 (1957). 9.	Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP, 591 U.S. 848, 863-64 (2020). 10.	Nat'l Ass'n for Advancement of Colored People v. State of Ala. ex rel. Patterson, 357 U.S. 449, 460 (1958); see also First Choice Women's Res. Centers, Inc. v. Davenport, 608 U.S. 174, 178 (2026) (recognizing that "government actions tending to 'curtai[l] the freedom to associate' warrant 'the closest scrutiny' under the First Amendment").

For context, this is the accompanying tweet which was sent by the author on the X social media platform:

His feed contains other similarly mean-spirited tweets.

*

One may think that talking of scalps, of gavels being wielded like tomahawks, and of arrow shots, is a strange and rather outdated way of discussing serious legal and constitutional matters – or indeed of discussing anything else.

(Of course, these are nasty references to the senator.)

But putting this racist, offensive and aggressive imagery to one side, what should we make of the legal substance of the letter?

*

The first question to ask of any litigation letter is: what is its purpose?

Why does a litigation letter exist and what difference does it make? But for the letter, how would the legal situation be different?

For a litigation letter which makes no difference is hardly a litigation letter at all.

*

Yesterday this blog brought out the Clear-o-Meter. This is a helpful device to assess the seriousness of any legal missive by how often the letter resorts to describing propositions as “clear”.

Fortunately today’s letter avoids the use of “clear” – though we will see the letter has other faults.

And so today we will employ another device for assessing litigation letters.

We will employ the Threat-o-Meter.

This device ascertains what, if anything, is actually being threatened in a litigation letter.

*

The most formidable and scary litigation letters are simple: “if you do [x], then [y] consequence shall follow”.

Such letters do not need aggressive, flowery language.

The bare “shall” ultimatum is enough.

Indeed, some of the most terrifying legal letters are often the politest.

These are the litigation letters which are rated Grade One on the Threat-o-Meter.

If those sending the letter do not do [y] in the event of [x] then senders lose credibility and may have abused litigation correspondence. That is why such letters (should) only use the “shall” ultimatum if it will actually be carried out.

(Also at the top of the Threat-o-Meter are the “we have already done [y]” – but those carry huge risks for those sending such a fait accompli letter.)

*

The next grade down on the Threat-o-Meter are what can be called the “may” letters.

These letters have as their essence “if you do [x], then [y] consequence may follow”.

To a lay person (that is a non-litigation lawyer) these Grade Two letters look very similar to Grade One letters – and to the lay recipient they can be as scary.

And often these Grade Two letters employ far more aggressive, flowery language than Grade One letters, so as to compensate for the “may” instead of the “shall”.

But the senders of these letters do not want to commit to a course of action if their demands are not met.

Sometimes they are vague on what the [y] consequence(s) will be.

The senders want the recipients to fear the potential consequences.

This can often be enough to ensure the recipient does what is demanded. Sometimes, indeed, the senders do have a point, and it is right that the recipient does what is demanded.

But these Grade Two letters are one good notch below the genuinely scary Grade One letters.

*

And then we come to Grade Three letters, where there is a legal point (or pretext) for the letter, but that purpose is below any specific demand for [x].

These Grade Three letters on the Threat-o-Meter are often in the form of the sender giving “notice” of something to recipient.

These letters are not without legal purpose. Placing a recipient on notice of something can change – indeed even transform – the legal position of the recipient. The law may require notice is given as a step in a given process.

As such these “notice” letters can serve a legal point.

But sometimes purportedly giving notice is an attempt to justify sending a letter when in fact no letter really needs to be sent.

(One tell of such a letter is that the sender is “reminding” the recipient of some requirement. This means the recipient already has the obligation and nothing is being changed by the letter is being sent.)

*

And finally there are litigation letters which are Grade Four on the Threat-o-Meter – where there is no legal point to the letter whatsoever.

These are often the most aggressive and flowery of all litigation letters.

*

Now let us look at the Reitz letter to Senator Warren.

It is a Grade Three “notice” letter on the Threat-o-Meter – with pretences of being a Grade Two “may” letter.

The key passage is (emphasis added):

“For these reasons, I am writing to give you formal notice of your obligation to preserve all documents, communications, and other electronically stored information relevant to your intent to weaponize congressional investigations and deprive citizens of their core constitutional rights in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 241 and 242.”

*

I am not an American lawyer, but it can be presumed that the document retention obligations in the United States are broadly similar to those in England and other common law jurisdictions. In essence, if you are placed on notice of contemplated litigation you need to preserve any relevant documents or other materials which may be evidence.

Here Reitz has specified two statutory provisions and he has stated there is contemplated litigation. This could trigger document retention obligations.

Of course, there is no reason to believe that Warren and her staff would not be retaining documents relevant to the investigations complained of.

After all, investigations are about accumulating documents and other evidence. Retaining documents is presumably what her team would be doing.

In essence, in this part of the letter all Reitz is demanding that Warren and her team do something that she would doubtless be doing anyway.

But it is (just) enough to provide a basis – a pretext – for a Grade Three letter on the Threat-o-Meter.

*

Reitz, however, want to make this seem a more aggressive letter than one merely giving notice of something.

He demands a response – to make it look like there is an ultimatum: “Please confirm in writing by 6:00 p.m. Eastern Time on November 23, 2026, that you have received this letter and have taken steps to preserve the materials described above.”

I do not know what the position in America is with these sort of demands for confirmation, but in England they can be an overreach – for unless there is an obligation to give such a confirmation, the recipient not providing a confirmation will make the senders look a bit silly. If the position is the same in America, Reitz may have been better not demanding a confirmation, and letting the notice stand by itself. After all, he will be able to evidence notice has been given: the confirmation of receipt would add nothing.

*

Reitz also tries to make it look like a “may” Grade Two letter.

He warns (emphasis added):

“Failure to do so may result in sanctions, adverse-inference instructions, or other penalties, and may carry significant legal consequences.”

He also deftly inserts “may” in this colourful passage (again, emphasis added):

“Your war cries directed at private American citizens and entities for associating with President Trump may run afoul of this constitutional right.”

*

Reitz cannot bring himself in this formal correspondence to say Warren and her team will breach constitutional rights – only that they “may” breach constitutional rights and that such breaches “may” have consequences if documents are not retained.

Giving notice of contemplated litigation which requires documents to be retained just about gives a pretext for sending the letter.

*

The author says this letter is an “arrow shot” – but it is an arrow without much of a point.

That is to say, Reitz’s arrow is not much of an arrow at all.

One thought on “A close reading of the legal threat made to Senator Warren”

  1. I heard a lawyer say yesterday that many actions of this administration amount to, “malevolence tempered by incompetence.”

    Perhaps Mr Reitz believes his letter is a work of genius. Mr Dunning and Mr Kruger would like a word.

Leave a Reply